By far the best pizza place I've eaten at in Colorado when it comes to taste. Their belly-o sandwiches are on another level too. One of my new go-to places when I don't know where to eat.
I'll start of by saying that I moved to Greeley 3 months ago after 9 years in Loveland and ordering from Pizza Street one to two times per week. The Loveland store was perfect, always got the order right, always on time, great staff. I've tried to order from the Greeley store 6 or 7 times sense moving here and have never even been able to get an order. It's one excuse after another. "We don't have change of a hundred". Who doesn't have change of a hundred on a 65 dollar order? And that doesn't include tip. They have closed at least 2 hours early at least twice when I've tried to order. They have been out of very common ingredients for pizza or menu items like wings. I've been treated rudely by staff. The funniest thing is I've asked to speak with the owner and was told he only comes in once or twice a week and only for around 15 minutes. It's sad that the Loveland location has to have their name tied to the Greeley store. Greeley Pizza Street is a joke. I would rather order MOD pizza, which is laughable and will never happen than "attempt" to order from Greeley Pizza Street again.
The pizza was decent but they wouldn't honor a valid coupon even though all the criteria for the coupon were met. Since they're looking for more business without following through on the deals they offer I will not be returning.
If u try the pepperoni rolls u will never order regular pizza again. It’s the nectar of the Greeley Gods. On Sundays they’re only $1 each. Best value on the planet. Just try them and tell me I’m wrong!
I was hungry and looking for a decent pizza. When the pizza i ordered arrived. It was a major disappointment. I mean, middle school cafeterias do a better job than this place. A good 30% of the pizza was missing cheese and toppings. Like what? Did ya'll run out of cheese? Or are you just cheap.
For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!