Papa John’s Pizza

4731 W 10th St, Greeley, CO 80634, USA

About Papa John’s Pizza

4.1 / 5

from reviews

    Scott Barela
    September 10, 2022

    This location truly cares about the quality of pizza they deliver. Pies looked great, crust was cooked to perfection, and flavor was amazing. With dropping standards in so many industries its nice to see one place that still cares.

    January 11, 2022

    Very disappointed with this delivery order. For starters, we wanted to try out the NY style pizza (we both lived in the tri-state area and wanted to see how PJ measured up), but we received what seems like a regular pan pizza. It wasn't thin enough a crust and did not fold... but there's another potential reason for that: our pizza was left on the door step without a knock or doorbell ring (which i specified in the notes); we have a dog that didn't even look up or do his usual alert when someone approaches the door. The pizza sat on our doormat long enough to get cold, for the cheese to be stiff, and the garlic sauce became more solidified. It looks great, and would have been decent (albeit, an incorrect order) if it wasn't cold. Also, the NY style pizza is advertised for $13 online, we did 3 toppings, added 2 garlic sauce (60 cents each) and it totaled to $28.15 for one pizza after taxes, fees, and tip. We haven't ordered from PJ in a long while, and after this experience, I can't think of a reason why we would in the future.

    PJ Ramirez
    August 05, 2022

    Haven't been there in a while as their pizza was just tasting blah. After about six months or more, I rec'd a great coupon so thought I'd try again. It was "any" two large pizzas for $20.00, silly me to believe that! Final cost with tax $28. What happened to any two. I was pleasantly surprised the pizza was really tasty this time. So we might try again soon, but be wary of those coupons!

    January 24, 2022

    Ordered extra sauce, still got no sauce. Zoom in on pics, literally no sauce. Am I supposed to put ketchup on it??! Done with Pappa John's. Dominoes, Fontas and Blackjack do much better.

    James “Jim” Powers
    February 10, 2022

    They do a great job in making a quality pizza. My only complaint would be that they need to sharpen or replace their cutter. Last two times (delivery and pickup), I have had to cut it when I got home.

    Papa John’s Pizza

    Our Address

    4731 W 10th St, Greeley, CO 80634, USA
    Get Directions

    Call Attention to Your Restaurant!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!